If there's no seals how can they tell it's been split? If RockAuto sold you a faulty alternator they should refund you in full. I agree it's faulty. Did you try initiating a return on their website?
https://www.rockauto.com/help/?page=4#PRTDMG they might be one of those suppliers that refuses to work over the phone (Summit Racing is way better about this type of stuff). I don't think anyone at the warehouse is going to scrutinize the part as long as it looks clean they should swap out no ?s asked.
If you have pay to ship it back it might be worthwhile to rebuild it yourself with some higher quality parts. I rebuilt my 12si with a
Powermaster Rebuild kit and put a 140 amp stator in it and it's better than a new alternator now. I'm sure there's upgraded CS style alternator rebuild kits too if you're running one of those on the LT1.