I'll put my two cents in here....I don't think it's worth that much cash...I'd throw $4500 cash in his grill and see what happens....YOu don't need this car and don't have to settle for it either...I bet as soon as you buy it, you'll find a better one out there at a better price...And Craigslist is like every other site...People ask more then what they really want....I perdonally don't like that era of Camaro's anyways.....Hell, I'd rather go after a Nova...Or better yet, buy another kickass G Body!!