Opinions will vary. Like which 5W-30 oil is best for my car. Either will make you happy when they're new.
If you get the proper pucks and washers/bolts, etc., either has advantages/disadvantages. Poly is likely to last a good long time, where the rubber will last a good while, but eventually will start to dry rot. Not saying they'll go bad soon, but the polys generally should outlive a rubber counterpart. If you don't get them real tight, polys COULD move on you and squeak. Usually not noticeable, but could be. Rubber bits don't usually squeak.
If you want it to LOOK factory, then go with black poly or factory bushings. The other colors just look stupid. Again, IMO. If you want it to BE factory fresh, go with the rubber. Depending on where you get them, you can usually buy the polys much cheaper than the GM ones, even if you can find them.They make aftermarket rubber ones, but I have no idea of their quality.
Kirban's sells a GM repro kit for 250.00. WITHOUT BOLTS I believe. Mike's Montes sells a similar kit with bolts for like 180.
You can check summit and places like that for poly stuff.
As for me, I'm going NOS rubber ones with GM bolts/washers. Because I'm going back totally stock.