I am probably gonna wind up sticking to the rust mort. I know it won't react with my primer, at least the way I've prepped it, it hasn't. I don't mind the price of the picklex if it works, but waiting for shipping sucks. I can run 5 minutes down the road and buy as much Rust Mort as I want.
I've personally had very mixed results with POR-15. Its holding up great on my rear gas tank in my Ford truck but that's about the only time I ever had good results with it. Plenty of people swear by it though.
But I'm really looking for a phosphoric acid type product that converts the rust to iron phosphate so that it no longer reacts with oxygen rather than a coating like POR to seal it. Most of the metal is im working with is clean, except for these small pits. I'm used to the Rust Mort product but I'm second guessing myself because of what my buddy told me.