I'm not an expert, but I recently had to learn all this for mine.
The round ear'd clutches are for the Coil pack posi, everyone makes them, and they will not work for the S-spring posi. I believe they have different dimensions.
As for clutch life and wear, I can't be much help. Mine has been on hold until I can round up the funds. It slips and needs new clutches, but I haven't had it apart and don't know what the worn ones look like.
If you decide to buy new clutches, here's the contact:
[email protected] , the name is Bruce, he charges $199, plus $5.35 shipping, total $204.35
I believe this same cost as GM charged when they produced them, but you also get clutch pack shims included.
The S-spring itself is still available thru some dealers.
http://gbodyparts.com/ carries some. I believe you can buy ones with different stiffness's.
the reason I have not yet bought the clutch pack... I am wanting to install larger gears, which requires setting up the carrier again, which requires a setup kit. Once you factor in all the costs, rebuilding my carrier with new clutches is nearly the cost of a new carrier. The new Coil pack style carriers are widely available, and all components are available for them as well.
If I was just refurbishing my carrier, without new gearing or re-setup, buying this clutch pack is by far the cheaper option