I thought about keeping my mouth shut ... but...
First of all, let me state that I love my G-Body Cutlass. In the past I've had numerous cars including 69 Camaro(s), a 69 Chevelle, 73 Pontiac Gran Prix, an 84 Cutlass with the 3.8 V6, Ford F-250 pickup, and my current daily driver is a 91
Buick LeSabre.
My current build is an 86 Cutlass which is getting a 385 SBC that will be fuel injected with Accel SuperRam, AFR heads, hydraulic roller cam and a Tremec Aftermarket T56 trans.
I myself don't see why guys are looked down upon just because they put the (yes) overused SBC in one. But then, there are numerous reasons why some guys use this motor. They are excellant motors. Some are better than others. I've built SBC's all my life so that's what I know best. My first Cutlass started out as a V6 3.8 and I had to get a differant engine in it to use as a daily driver. I had a 350 Chevy I did a stock rebuild on so I dropped that in it. It turned it into a really fun driver that took me on many road trips over several years. Replacement parts (the few that were needed) were plentiful anywhere.
Olds motors are good motors, too. I've seen several that I wouldn't mind owning. But, I didn't have any. When I swapped out my V6 I couldn't really see going out and buying an Olds engine core and rebuilding it and then searching the yards for all the correct mounts and bracketery that I would need to plant said Olds motor in my car. I didn't have the time as I needed a running car ASAP. I didn't really have the cash to procure all the necessary parts to put in the Olds engine. I had a stash of Chevy parts that would meet my objective at the time. I used what I had.
The old Cutlass served me well for a few years. Had a lot of fun in that car. It wasn't everyone's cup of tea but it was mine and I liked it! So much so, when I had to choose one car to keep and one to get rid of, I got rid of my 69 Camaro I'd had for over 15 years. That shocked MANY people! Well, mother nature caught up to my old friend and cancer ended her life. Just way too much for me to have cured. I bought a replacement at that time. I could have bought a Monte or a Camaro or a Nissan for that matter. I found another Cutlass, an 86, and I had to have it. It was a fairly rust-free (for Southern Illinois) body that needed a motor. Hmmm... I have everything to put a motor in that car... Yes, it had an Olds enginge in it. The famous 307. I could've rebuilt the 307. And I'd still have a 307. But seeing I wouldn't waste my time on a 305 SBC either, that 307 wasn't an option in my mind. I don't see as many Regal guys catching sh*t for not running Buick V8. What about the Gran Prix guys using their Pontiac motors. They all had good V8's, too
As far as Olds motors being better or worse than Chevy engines, well, I can say this. It really depends on how they're built. We need to compare like-wise engines. Compare a built 455 to a stock SBC and yeah, the Olds will be faster. Chevy guys could compare a built 406 to a stone stock 307, too. I'm not here to say one is better than the other. I've seen good and bad in both brands. I've seen both last to well over 250,000 miles. It depends on how they're built, for what purpose, with what parts, and how they're maintained.
It would've been silly of me to sell all my Chevy parts and buy Olds parts just to keep an Olds engine in an Olds car. My car has progressed to what it is. If I do sell all my SBC stuff I'll be buying LSx parts anyway.
Did anybody look down on the moonshiners when they started putting Caddy engines in '40 Fords? I guess the revenuers did when they couldn't catch them. I thought hot rodding was all about swapping parts to make your ride faster or better. I didn't know there were *rules* that rodders couldn't break. I always thought rodders were *rule-breakers* or rebels to begin with. At least it was a Supreme and not a 442 or
H/O.
Jeez... build your car. With what you got, or can get. Be damned with what others think of it and respect others for what they built. I don't like ricers but I respect the power they can get from them. I don't like donks but they put a lot of time and money in them.
Spend a little more time enjoying *our* cars and less time nit-picking others.
Okay, I'm done ranting now. Someone else's turn on this soap box...