I have only bought 1 set of gears brand new and they were from Richmond and they were great. I actually use GM gears when I can find good examples at swap meets or when I am lucky enough to bump into John from Gevo's gears. http://rearsgears.com/ He sells mint used gears and even once hooked me up with a set of gears and posi carrier for my '68 Buick LeSabre. The factory manual has specs for used gears and bearings so no worry about durability. For severe duty you of course would want new racing quality gears but I expect stock GM or any brand to last forever when set up correctly and the lube maintained.