Okay, it could be possible that the gauge is faulty. But right now I am wondering if you have tried to drive the car with that new sending unit plugged in and wired in to see what the gauge does when the motor has a chance to get hot enough that the thermostat can open versus it just sitting there. Where I am going with this is that if the thermostat hadn't opened during the short time that the vehicle had been idling then what you may have run into was a hot spot or bubble in the coolant because it wasn't circulating through the rad, only internally in the block. I have watched gauges head for the boiling point only for the needle to drop like a rock when the t-stat pops open and the coolant gets to cycle though the rad. Possibly take an around the block test drive and them come back and check your coolant level to see if it has gone down because the t-stat has opened and allowed the coolant to return back to the rad.
WARNING!
If you are possible thinking of doing that coolant check at the radiator, Do It With The Engine Running!! if you try to unscrew the rad cap with the engine turned off the internal coolant pressure will blow the coolant out of the rad tank through the filller neck and into your face and body. This equals instant burns to face, hands, eyes, and upper body, and possibly internal poisoning if you ingest the hot liquid. (Don't laugh, you would be surprised how many people tend to stand there with their mouth open while they try to get eyeball close to the radiator coolant filler neck so that they can see what is going on inside the tank.)
Nick
WARNING!
If you are possible thinking of doing that coolant check at the radiator, Do It With The Engine Running!! if you try to unscrew the rad cap with the engine turned off the internal coolant pressure will blow the coolant out of the rad tank through the filller neck and into your face and body. This equals instant burns to face, hands, eyes, and upper body, and possibly internal poisoning if you ingest the hot liquid. (Don't laugh, you would be surprised how many people tend to stand there with their mouth open while they try to get eyeball close to the radiator coolant filler neck so that they can see what is going on inside the tank.)
Nick