After I did my dash swap I had some similiar problems. My temp gauge moves slow and then it will bounce up real high, the oil pressure will be normal and then peg full and then bounce around, cheap sending units maybe? My volt is ok, usually sits on 14 and then settles down as I drive. The tach will read high for a while then it will settle down and be normal. As far as the fuel I dont know how accurate it is. I usually fill up at 1/4 tank and since I have only put 3 tanks thru it in a yr its hard to tell. I would look for the grounds and make sure they are good. Mine are good but I did buy 2 dashes used and they both read different. I had issues with the connections in the dash plug.