I have a shelterlogic carport tent, the one thats fully enclosed. I've had it for maybe 5 years now? Just retarped it this summer. I ran into a minor snag with my town, someone complained about my tent (which I put up without a permit, out of plain sight, on the side of my house, behind a 6' fence/gate...) so the zoning officer set me up with a legal spot and I moved it to the middle of my yard! Now its legal and I even have a c/o for it.
None-the-less, for the $200 for the tent, and maybe $200-$400 in gravel, tarps, permits, ect... it has served me well. I put a heavy duty tarp between the original tarp and the poles to reinforce it, there is a tarp on the floor as a moisture barrier, and make sure you brush off any snow load, during a big storm I do it multiple times.
None-the-less, for the $200 for the tent, and maybe $200-$400 in gravel, tarps, permits, ect... it has served me well. I put a heavy duty tarp between the original tarp and the poles to reinforce it, there is a tarp on the floor as a moisture barrier, and make sure you brush off any snow load, during a big storm I do it multiple times.