I vote for getting it mixed or buying a pint of single stage based off the paint code. I've used https://www.automotivetouchup.com/index.htm before with "meh" results. The paint shop pint was much closer in color, although it had a bunch more metal flake in it.
This is the site I was looking at yesterday, was hoping there would be feedback on a specific site(s). I plan to call 1-2 local places and see what they say. I can see a paint place not wanting to bother for a small amount and that's where these sites step in if they specialize in that.
I did buy a $3 can of "smoky beige" at Menards that I planned to test. Satin finish but the color is pretty close. 😊
Color is paint code 63, medium beige.