I've had the (mis)pleasure of having to go to NYC.... any dumping is well deserved.
I think "upstate" new york should build a series of pipelines for all their municipal sewage to converge around Nyack, then dump it into the Hudson - treated, but smelly, and give back to NYC as much sh*t as it gives the rest of the state....
People are accustom to city life, and I believe that goes double for NYC, but I could be wrong. To each his own regarding where you live and where you are happy living.
The issue I have with downstate, from my upstate perspective, is not someone's choice to live there or my lack of enthusiasm for the area, but rather that we have to abide by what comes out of there - the law that is the subject of this thread.