the 8.5 is a pretty stout rear end and they are a direct bolt in. the 12 bolt if you want to stay GM is the way to go. I'm getting ready to switch to a ford 9. if you are going to change gears often i would say the 9" is the best and I'm gonna change gears for race and for street so thats the route i took. which ever way you go is is pretty much better than a 7.5 but if money is tight throw a spool in the 7.5 or a decent posi if you can find one for cheap. i have yet to break mine and I'm not gentle on it. granted I'm only making about 375 hp and I'm not putting slicks on it but knock on wood its still together.