If you'd have used Olds console parts, they would have fit. 🙂
Seriously, that's one of the biggest issues I have with most of the repro parts for interior. It's like they get them ALMOST good enough to fit, but then fall short on the finished product. I wouldn't mind spending a bit more on stuff like this if you could just pop it out of the box, paint it to your liking or whatever, and when you go to install it fits right up like the original. It's almost as if the Chinesium cannot be molded to the correct shape. I get the nuances of adjustment holes and what not, but you would think that 99% of it does not change dimensions from car to car. Get it right the first time so people will recommend your parts instead of making people choose between worn out parts and your new non-fitting- without-major-mods-junk.
But you persevered and made it work like it should. Looks great! And the CF touches make it blend nicely with the rest of the CF motif. Look at it like this, at least you don't have to tune the console!
I've only heard the stories of the repro Olds console lids like this. I do have one I bought as a "just in case" but the outer skin/shape, etc. is almost spot on to the original as far as looks. As far as fitment, I've never tried it.